Plot Your Book with Ease: The Ultimate 5x40 Novel Outline
Ready to turn your story sparks into a full-fledged outline? Discover the 5x40 trick! #AmWriting
This is a long post. You may want to read it online.
Hey there, 👋
Have you ever had a great idea for a story and then frozen once you sit down to map out your chapters? You’re not alone. Many of us start drafting with a head full of characters and conflicts but no clear direction. Before you know it, you’re halfway through a messy draft, struggling to connect key events and keep the tension alive.
Today, we’re going to tackle that very problem. Think of your outline like a trusty compass: it may not dictate every single step, but it keeps you from wandering in circles. By the end of this guide, you’ll have a straightforward, five-step approach to structuring your novel, ideally landing on about 40 scenes. This number might fluctuate a bit, but it’s a dependable target for many commercial fiction manuscripts—providing enough room for rich character arcs without bogging down your pacing.
Why Is Outlining So Tricky?
Writers often resist outlining because it can feel restrictive or rigid. You might worry that plotting everything in advance will squash any chance of spontaneity. Or maybe you’ve tried outlines before, only to discover your story veering off course two chapters later. These fears are valid, but they don’t have to stop you from using a roadmap.
Let’s look at a few relatable pitfalls:
Overwhelm: You have enough story ideas to fill a trilogy, but no clue how to break them down into manageable scenes.
Lack of Clarity: Your protagonist seems flat or aimless because you haven’t pinned down what they want—or why they want it.
Fear of Losing Creativity: You worry that once you write something down in an outline, you’re stuck with it, even if a better idea strikes later.
That last one is especially common. But think about how authors like J.K. Rowling meticulously planned Harry Potter—each book still brims with discovery and surprise. In a different genre altogether, Gillian Flynn’s Gone Girl is a masterclass in carefully plotted twists, yet it never feels formulaic. These writers show us that outline and inspiration don’t cancel each other out; they can enhance each other when done right.
On an emotional level, writing can feel lonely and uncertain when you don’t know your next step. We’ve all stared at a blank page, shoulders slumped, feeling like we’ve lost our storyline. That’s exactly why a clear, but flexible, outline is such a lifesaver. It gives you confidence, direction, and the freedom to deviate when a sudden flash of brilliance calls for it.
The 5-Step, 40-Scene Approach
To tackle these challenges, we’ll focus on a simple “5x40” approach—five key stages of your novel, each broken into a set of scenes that build your story logically and emotionally. Here’s a quick overview:
Concept & Theme: Define the emotional core of your story.
Turning Points: Outline the major shifts or beats.
Act Structures: Divide your novel into segments (usually three or four acts) and place your turning points.
Character Arcs: Ensure each character experiences change and growth that aligns with your turning points.
Scene-Level Details: Craft each scene with purpose, aiming for around 40 total to keep the story tightly focused.
This framework might remind you of classic story structures like the Hero’s Journey or Save the Cat, but it’s flexible. In The Hunger Games (YA dystopian), Suzanne Collins uses clear act divisions—The Reaping, The Games, The Aftermath—yet she weaves in organic character growth. Your goal is to find a structure that works for your story, whether you’re writing a cozy mystery or a sweeping fantasy epic.
Foundational Steps
Let’s break down each foundational stage in a bit more detail, so you know exactly how to move from a blank page to a working outline.
1. Pinpoint Your Story’s Compass (Concept & Theme)
Why It Matters:
Your theme is the heart of your novel. It’s the question or idea you’re exploring—love conquers all, justice vs. revenge, or personal freedom. It acts like a lighthouse, guiding every scene toward a greater purpose.
Tip:
Ask yourself, What keeps my protagonist up at night? Perhaps they’re wrestling with guilt (like in Dostoevsky’s Crime and Punishment). Or maybe they’re yearning for social acceptance in a restrictive world (think Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen). Frame that as a driving question—Will my protagonist overcome X to achieve Y? Jot it down before you start any detailed outlining.
2. Identify Major Turning Points
Why It Matters:
Turning points are those pivotal moments when your character’s journey pivots—new information comes to light, a mentor steps in, or a crisis forces a change. They keep your plot from feeling flat.
Tip:
Think of them like stepping stones across a river. You should have 2-4 major shifts throughout your story, depending on how many acts you like to use. For instance, in The Great Gatsby, we have:
Meeting Daisy again (dream reawakened),
The confrontation in the Plaza Hotel (dream under threat),
The tragic car accident (dream shattered).
Each turning point alters Gatsby’s trajectory. Similarly, outline yours to see how your character’s goals evolve or intensify.
3. Map Out Your Acts
Why It Matters:
Most commercial fiction divides nicely into three or four acts. The first act sets the stage, the second deepens conflict, the third (and fourth if you use a quartet structure) ramps up to the climax and resolves. It’s a tried-and-true way to ensure your story has momentum.
Tip:
Sketch out your acts as broad strokes first:
Act I: Who are we following, and what do they want?
Act II: Raise the stakes. Introduce dilemmas and obstacles.
Act III (and IV if used): Deliver the climax and tie up loose ends.
When you’re drafting your scenes, tuck them under the relevant act. This helps you balance setup, escalation, and resolution.
4. Weave in Character Arcs
Why It Matters:
Readers don’t just care about what happens; they care about who it happens to. Without growth or transformation, even the most action-packed story can feel shallow. In Gone Girl, both Nick and Amy have arcs that twist in morally ambiguous ways, fueling the tension.
Tip:
Focus on your protagonist’s emotional evolution alongside the plot. In each act, ask: How does this new conflict change my protagonist’s outlook? Then do the same for at least one major side character to ensure they also feel real. If your protagonist starts off timid, let them confront situations that chip away at that timidity. By your final act, they might make a bold move that was unthinkable at the story’s start.
5. Break It Down Scene by Scene
Why 40 Scenes?
“40” is a ballpark figure often used for a medium-length novel (70,000 to 90,000 words). It’s enough scenes to develop complex subplots yet remains a manageable structure. Each scene should have a clear purpose—whether it’s to reveal new information, deepen conflict, or change the character’s emotional state.
Tip:
Try to keep each scene about one key event or emotional turn. If you find yourself cramming too much in one scene, split it. If a scene feels pointless, cut it or merge it into another. Focus on cause and effect: each scene’s outcome should lead logically to the next scene’s setup.
Simple Example: From Blank Page to Solid Structure
Imagine you’re plotting a mystery novel involving a small-town librarian who stumbles upon a local political scandal.
Theme & Concept: Sometimes the quietest places hold the darkest secrets.
Major Turning Points:
The librarian finds a suspicious ledger in the archives.
A key suspect is murdered, raising the stakes.
The final showdown reveals the real culprit’s unexpected motive.
Acts:
Act I: Establish the sleepy town and the librarian’s curiosity.
Act II: Heighten the danger as she investigates and personal relationships crumble.
Act III: Climax in a final confrontation, followed by resolution.
Character Arc:
Protagonist starts timid, unsure of her detective skills.
Gains confidence as she pieces clues together, losing friends in the process.
Overcomes her fears in the final unmasking of the criminal.
Scene Count:
Aim for around 12-14 scenes per act, each raising or resolving a specific question.
When you lay it out like this, you can easily see where to insert revelations, cliffhangers, and emotional beats.
Basic Pitfalls (And How to Avoid Them)
Overloading Act I
It’s tempting to cram all world-building and backstory into the first few chapters. The Hunger Games cleverly reveals just enough about Panem’s grim world before the Reaping to hook us, saving deeper details for later scenes. Spread your background info out and let readers discover it organically.A Meandering Middle
The second act is notorious for sagging if you don’t escalate conflict. Consider throwing a wrench in your protagonist’s plans—maybe a trusted ally betrays them, or a new threat appears. Keep tension high so you avoid that dreaded “middle slump.”Rushed Endings
Nobody likes investing in a book only to feel the ending was slapped together. Make sure your final scenes deliver on the promises you made earlier. Tie up loose ends, but allow room for a little ambiguity or reflection if it suits your genre.
A well-thought-out outline helps prevent these pitfalls, serving as a reminder of where your characters are coming from and where they’re headed.
Bringing It Together
By now, you should feel more comfortable with the idea of structuring your novel using five clear steps—concept/theme, turning points, act divisions, character arcs, and scene-by-scene breakdown. With this approach, you can confidently aim for around 40 scenes, giving your story a robust, engaging shape without stifling creativity.
Rest assured you have a solid foundation to craft a compelling narrative from start to finish. The blank page isn’t so daunting anymore, is it?
Go on—dust off that story idea and start mapping your path. Each scene you plan is a step closer to typing “The End” on a novel that feels cohesive, dynamic, and uniquely yours.
In the next part of this article, I’ll share some AI prompts that can lighten the load of outlining even further—especially if you love brainstorming or want quick ways to iterate on your scene ideas.
Want to write more, stress less, and get published faster? Alt Author gives you tools and insights tailored for indie authors. Stay ahead of the curve—become a free or paid subscriber now and start creating your best work yet!
AI Prompts and Strategies for Plot Outlining
Now that you’ve got a solid framework for plotting your novel, it’s time to see how AI can supercharge your creative process. Think of AI as a brainstorming partner who never gets tired, always ready with new ideas, plot twists, or character arcs. With the right prompts, you can quickly build on your story’s foundation—then tweak, refine, or even pivot as fresh inspiration strikes.
Below, you’ll find a series of detailed prompts you can feed into your favorite AI writing tool (e.g., ChatGPT, Claude, or others). Feel free to adapt them to your novel’s genre, setting, or tone. The more specific and detailed you make your questions, the more targeted and useful the AI’s output will be.
Master Prompt: Generate Story Concepts
If you don’t have a solid idea for your novel, no worries! Let’s start by generating a handful of high-level story premises. Whether you’re still searching for “the one” or simply want to compare multiple options, this prompt will help you jumpstart the creative process.